A federal appeals court has reinstated the jury verdict finding that the NFL violated antitrust law through its Sunday Ticket out-of-market package, putting the league back on the hook in a case it believed it had closed in 2024. On October 30, a three-judge panel of the Ninth Circuit reversed District Judge Philip Gutierrezs judgment for the league, upheld his decision to set aside the original damages award of roughly $4.7 billion, and ordered a new trial to determine how much the NFL must pay.

The class action, filed in 2015, covers roughly 2.4 million residential subscribers and 48,000 bars, restaurants and other businesses that bought Sunday Ticket through DirecTV, which distributed the package for nearly three decades. Plaintiffs argued that the league and its clubs pooled out-of-market telecasts into a single premium bundle rather than letting fans buy individual teams, inflating prices. A Los Angeles jury agreed in June 2024. Gutierrez then excluded the plaintiffs expert economic testimony and ruled for the NFL. The panel found he exceeded his authority by doing so after the jury had already weighed that evidence, but agreed the damages calculation was flawed. Because antitrust damages can be tripled, exposure in the first trial exceeded $14 billion. The NFL said it was disappointed, called its model the most fan-friendly distribution approach in sports, and is considering further appellate review.

The strategic significance lies less in the eventual payment than in what the liability finding says about the leagues distribution architecture. Sunday Ticket is a premium layer above free national and regional broadcasts, and its pricing has long been justified as protecting the value of those broadcast deals. A standing verdict confirms that a jury can treat that structure as an anticompetitive restraint rather than legitimate product design. Even if damages are recalculated well below the original figure, the NFL now carries a contingent liability into a period in which it is positioning to renegotiate its media agreements early and seek higher fees.

The package moved to YouTube in 2023 under a seven-year agreement reportedly worth $14 billion. That deal is not directly at issue, because the claims concern the DirecTV years. But the ruling sends a clear signal to future buyers and to the leagues own negotiators: how out-of-market inventory is bundled and priced is now a litigation variable, not only a commercial one. For other leagues selling out-of-market packages, the case remains the most closely watched test of how far pooled rights can be monetised before antitrust exposure follows. The damages retrial, and any petition for rehearing or Supreme Court review, will set the size of the bill. The reinstated verdict has already shifted the leverage around it.